She was thirty-nine years old when they married, and he forty-four.
Hudson, Derek, and Arthur Joseph Munby. Munby, Man of Two Worlds. J. Murray, 1972.
318
Munby's family knew neither of Hannah nor of the marriage until after his death.
Cullwick, Hannah. “Introduction and Notes”. The Diaries of Hannah Cullwick, Victorian Maidservant, edited by Liz Stanley, Rutgers University Press, 1984, pp. 1 - 28, passim.
188
The marriage was childless. There is some dispute as to whether it was consummated. Although Munby asked her to call him Arthur from this point, she persisted with Massa.
Hudson, Derek, and Arthur Joseph Munby. Munby, Man of Two Worlds. J. Murray, 1972.
318
Munby continued with his life much as before. Although he lived in chambers, he did not practise as a barrister, but worked as a clerk at the Ecclesiastical Commissioners
, lectured at the Working Women's College
(where he taught Latin to classes of women), and wrote.
Cullwick, Hannah. “Introduction and Notes”. The Diaries of Hannah Cullwick, Victorian Maidservant, edited by Liz Stanley, Rutgers University Press, 1984, pp. 1 - 28, passim.
22, 33, 101
Hudson, Derek, and Arthur Joseph Munby. Munby, Man of Two Worlds. J. Murray, 1972.
215
Munby was also an acquaintance of Barbara Leigh Smith Bodichon
, herself rather differently interested in women's work. Of her suffrage petition he commented in his diary, let them vote by all means, if they will also work.
qtd. in
Hudson, Derek, and Arthur Joseph Munby. Munby, Man of Two Worlds. J. Murray, 1972.
In the tradition of her father, EAD
espoused strong Liberal views. She campaigned non-violently for women's rights and women's suffrage, and she participated in a woman's strike in 1911. She also worked to improve education and health services. After the Qualification of Women Act made women eligible for local government in 1907, she ran for election to the Swansea borough council, but was defeated.
Matthew, Henry Colin Gray et al., editors. Oxford Dictionary of National Biography. http://www.oxforddnb.com/.
Blain, Virginia et al., editors. The Feminist Companion to Literature in English: Women Writers from the Middle Ages to the Present. Yale University Press; Batsford, 1990.
As the Cambrian Leader bluntly explained, she could be criticised on one point only, but that was decisive: She is a woman, not a man. The sex disability is, however, so real that her . . . administrative ability and freedom from the feminine idiosyncracies which might prove embarrassing at gatherings of business-men failed to remove it.
qtd. in
Painting, David. Amy Dillwyn. University of Wales, 1987.
Since it appeared amidst heady discussions regarding the Woman Question, including questions about marriage, female employment, rational dress, and suffrage, the book's lighthearted, humorous tone belies its covertly subversive potential. MMD
does not attempt a treatise on the equality of men and women; instead she describes female autonomy and self-sufficiency through her story of a woman travelling alone with no need for a gentleman's assistance. Her only overt statement about gender occurs in her preface to the fourth edition of the book, when she argues for the socially-constructed nature of men and women alike, writing: Men and women, grown in the same conditions of air, light, and nutriment, will be found of equal gifts if they be compared . . . for a practical experiment [let us try] to sell grass some day: pluck a handful for sample from the open meadow, and another from beneath a grey yard-tile; is there any one who will expect this latter handful to make good sweet hay?
Dowie, Ménie Muriel. A Girl in the Karpathians. Fifth Edition, George Philip & Son, 1892.
Kirk, John Foster, and S. Austin Allibone, editors. A Supplement to Allibone’s Critical Dictionary of English Literature and British and American Authors. J. B. Lippincott, 1891, 2 vols.
GE
was always ambivalent about the struggle for women's rights. This ambivalence may have been fed by the fact that her situation with Lewes made her peculiarly vulnerable to public attack of a personal flavour. The divided nature of her views is well captured in two comments she made to the same correspondent, prominent feminist Clementia Taylor
. Having declared her sympathy with the desire to see women socially elevated—educated equally with men,
Eliot, George. The George Eliot Letters. Editor Haight, Gordon S., Yale University Press, 1954–1978, 9 vols.
4: 366
she gently rebuked her friend years later for having failed to understand that I have grave reasons for not speaking on certain public topics. Her function, she said, was that of the aesthetic, not the doctrinal teacher—the rousing of the nobler emotions, which make mankind desire the social right, not the prescribing of special measures.
Eliot, George. The George Eliot Letters. Editor Haight, Gordon S., Yale University Press, 1954–1978, 9 vols.
7: 44
She did, however, write in her meditation on the movement to improve women's lot: Unfortunately, many over-zealous champions of women assert their actual equality with men—nay, even their moral superiority to men—as a ground for their release from oppressive laws and restrictions. They lose strength immensely by this false position. If it were true, then there would be a case in which slavery and ignorance nourished virtue, and so far we should have an argument for the continuance of bondage.
Eliot, George. Essays of George Eliot. Editor Pinney, Thomas, Columbia University Press, 1963.
205
She signed and sought further signatures for Barbara Leigh Smith
's Married Women's Property petition, which she saw as a counteractive to wife-beating and other evils.
Eliot, George. The George Eliot Letters. Editor Haight, Gordon S., Yale University Press, 1954–1978, 9 vols.
2: 225
She attended some lectures at Bedford College for Women
and supported the cause of women's education in practical ways (like small gifts of money to the fund being raised for Girton College
), but she held back from the suffrage question.
Ashton, Rosemary. George Eliot: A Life. Hamish Hamilton, 1996.
291-2
David, Deirdre. Intellectual Women and Victorian Patriarchy. Cornell University Press, 1987.
The text addresses a number of issues affecting women, including suffrage, inadequate incomes, divorce legislation, and attitudes toward motherhood. Farr's immersion in mysticism and the occult is often evident, as when she advises her women readers to look forward to the great century that is waiting for their alchemy,
Farr, Florence. Modern Woman: Her Intentions. Frank Palmer, 1910.
92
or encourages them to tap into their torpid or vegetative consciousness.
In the latter, she is influenced by Henri Bergson
's ideas about creative evolution.
The book suffers from its dependence on eugenic and racist theories; its preface, for instance, attributes the degradation of women to the white races' adoption of the Assyrian Semite's Scriptures and suggests that [w]omen have a very long score to settle with the Jews and the Mahommedans . . . I can only hope that it was ignorance and not malice that led the Jews and the Arabs to spread false doctrine on the subject of sex.
Farr, Florence. Modern Woman: Her Intentions. Frank Palmer, 1910.
Katharine
and Edith
joined the University College
debating society, where they tried out their arguments in favour of women's suffrage and the anti-vivisection movement—they were involved in both causes for several years.
Matthew, Henry Colin Gray et al., editors. Oxford Dictionary of National Biography. http://www.oxforddnb.com/.
Todd, Janet, editor. Dictionary of British Women Writers. Routledge, 1989.
Stang, Sondra J., editor. “Introduction and Editorial Materials”. The Ford Madox Ford Reader, Carcanet, 1986, p. various pages.
304
published a suffrage pamphlet, This Monstrous Regiment of Women, with the Minerva Publishing Co. for the Women's Freedom League
.
Stang
gives the date as 1912, but Harvey
suggests early 1913. A review appeared in The Common Cause on 1 August 1913. OCLC WorldCat, which records copies dated in each of these two year, guesses that it appeared by March 1913.
Stang, Sondra J., editor. “Introduction and Editorial Materials”. The Ford Madox Ford Reader, Carcanet, 1986, p. various pages.
304
Harvey, David Dow. Ford Madox Ford, 1873-1939: A Bibliography of Works and Criticism. Princeton University Press, 1962.
38
“Dictionary of Literary Biography online”. Gale Databases: Literature Resource Center-LRC.
CFT
's first novel shows an interest in the position of the working classes that seems to have been intensified after her marriage and move to Jarrow. She found in her husband, the educated and book-loving Edward Thomas Liddell
, a sympathetic partner. A Christian socialist, a liberal, a champion of the poor in his parish work, and a supporter of female suffrage, he persuaded her early in their relationship to read John Stuart Mill
's The Subjection of Women.
Fraser-Tytler, Christina. A Shepherd of the Sheep. Longmans, Green, 1916.
The impact of the exhibition, however, was lasting. Hermione Lee
makes a link between the exhibition and Woolf's famous remark that in December 1910, human character changed.
Lee, Hermione. Virginia Woolf. Chatto and Windus, 1996.
287, 290
Lee also observes that the rhetoric of hostility to the suffrage movement and the Post-Impressionist exhibition was astonishingly similar . . . the shock of the new sprang from fears about sexual identity, racial and national survival.
Lee, Hermione. Virginia Woolf. Chatto and Windus, 1996.
Once back in America, FW
began to lecture again on social questions, particularly slavery, female suffrage, and the evils of banks. These years in the USA, and her work there, were made difficult by those who not only opposed her political views, but also viewed and publicly presented her as a dangerous and deviant woman.
Stephen, Sir Leslie, and Sidney Lee, editors. The Dictionary of National Biography. Smith, Elder, 1908–2025, 22 vols. plus supplements.
Eckhardt, Celia Morris. Fanny Wright. Harvard University Press, 1984.
In her study of Golden Gates, critic Molly Youngkin
notes that from 1892 it became increasingly concerned with gender and social issues. In a memorable response to Eliza Lynn Linton
's piece The Wild Women as Social Insurgents (in The Nineteenth Century), JSW
agrees with Linton's anti-suffrage position, but takes issue with her portrait of a modern girl. This, Winter argues, constitutes a straw figure, an imaginary nine-pin
qtd. in
Youngkin, Molly. “"Independent in Thought and Expression, Kindly and Tolerant in Tone": Henrietta Stannard, Golden Gates, and Gender Controversies in Fin-de-Siècle Periodicals”. Victorian Periodicals Review, Vol.
38
, No. 3, 2005, pp. 307-29.
310
created solely to be knocked down. Ashton describes Winter as being in her journal at least a cautious advocate of [women's] increased emancipation and participation in the public domain,
Ashton, Owen. “Henrietta Stannard and the Social Emancipation of Women, 1890-1910”. The Duty of Discontent: Essays for Dorothy Thompson, edited by Owen Ashton et al., Mansell, 1995, pp. 167-90.
175
and notes that she wrote against relegating middle-class women solely to the society treadmill, lest they become utterly narrow and cramped in . . . mind.
qtd. in
Ashton, Owen. “Henrietta Stannard and the Social Emancipation of Women, 1890-1910”. The Duty of Discontent: Essays for Dorothy Thompson, edited by Owen Ashton et al., Mansell, 1995, pp. 167-90.
Following the granting to women on 2 July 1928 of voting rights equal to those of men, AWE
published a handbook for electors on exercising their suffrage rights: Why Should I Vote?
The title continues: To Retain Them in Political, and Thence in Civil and Domestic, Slavery. Wheeler's name did not appear on the original title-page, but Thompson claimed that she was responsible for the much of the text. The Appeal responded to James Mill
's 1824 article on government for the yearly supplement to the Encyclopaedia Britannnica. Mill denied women the right to suffrage on the grounds that their interests, similarly to those of children, were included in those of their fathers and husbands.
Kelly, Gary, editor. Dictionary of Literary Biography 158. Gale Research, 1996.
350
Thompson, William et al. Appeal of One Half the Human Race, Women. Thoemmes, 1994.
title-page
Critic Dolores Dooley
believes that AW
was solely responsible for the searing critique and analysis of the institution of marriage.
Matthew, Henry Colin Gray et al., editors. Oxford Dictionary of National Biography. http://www.oxforddnb.com/.
Critics have considered ELV
's fiction unusual for the late Victorian period, particularly for her treatment of female protagonists and the focus on mental or physical pain.
Garlick, Barbara. Victorian Britain: An Encyclopedia. Editor Mitchell, Sally, Garland Publishing, Inc., 1988, p. 837.
837
Showalter, Elaine. A Literature of Their Own. Princeton University Press, 1977.
63, 192-3
Her feminism shines through her work, but she generally eschews popular causes like the struggle for the suffrage to advocate through strong female characters more radical and extensive social change.
Garlick, Barbara. Victorian Britain: An Encyclopedia. Editor Mitchell, Sally, Garland Publishing, Inc., 1988, p. 837.
837
Showalter, Elaine. A Literature of Their Own. Princeton University Press, 1977.
63, 192
She does not write of tender or romantic attachment between men and women leading to motherhood and family life.
Kennedy, Gerry. The Booles & The Hintons: Two dynasties that helped shape the modern world. Cork University Press, 2016.
His career forced him to move to China in 1841, and his family followed shortly afterwards without the five- or six-year-old Linda.
Blain, Virginia et al., editors. The Feminist Companion to Literature in English: Women Writers from the Middle Ages to the Present. Yale University Press; Batsford, 1990.
She remained in England instead, living with her great-aunt and a close friend of her mother.
Blain, Virginia et al., editors. The Feminist Companion to Literature in English: Women Writers from the Middle Ages to the Present. Yale University Press; Batsford, 1990.
Villari, Linda. When I Was a Child, or Left Behind. T. Fisher Unwin, 1885.
52
After her family returned, her father was elected as a Liberal MP to the British House of Commons
for Plymouth in 1857 when Linda was twenty-one, and for Brighton in 1860. Brighton returned two members: James White's fellow representative from 1865 was Henry Fawcett
, husband of the future suffrage leader Millicent Garrett Fawcett
, who served as her blind husband's secretary while he was in parliament.
“The Times Digital Archive 1785-2007”. Thompson Gale: The Times Digital Archive.
40928 (9 August 1915): 10
Matthew, Henry Colin Gray et al., editors. Oxford Dictionary of National Biography. http://www.oxforddnb.com/.
under Henry Fawcett
As this association suggests, James White was a man of progressive opinions; he was a friend of Italian patriots such as Giuseppe Garibaldi
. He died on 9 January 1883.
“The Times Digital Archive 1785-2007”. Thompson Gale: The Times Digital Archive.
ST
gave an address in New York at the first meeting of the American Equal Rights Association
(an organization dedicated to securing suffrage rights irrespective of race or gender).
Mullane, Deirdre, editor. Crossing the Danger Water: Three hundred years of African-American writing. Anchor, 1993.
This book opens by looking back just over a century, when John Stuart Mill
presented petitions to parliament on behalf of women's suffrage in 1866 and 1867. It relates the story of the suffragist movement, paying due attention to Emmeline Pankhurst
and possibly more than her due to Emily Davison
, who threw herself under the king's horse on Derby Day.
Emily Wilding Davison, who worked as a governess and a teacher, was a strong-minded woman often at odds with authority. Before she ran out onto the Derby course under the horses (and died of her injuries some days later) she had been consistently at odds with authority, including WSPU
leaders.
Matthew, Henry Colin Gray et al., editors. Oxford Dictionary of National Biography. http://www.oxforddnb.com/.
under Emily Wilding Davison
The book comes close enough to the present day to mention the very early career of Germaine Greer
.
It rests on the shoulders of a canvasser to persuade the citizens met in this play that their votes may make a difference. The play is reminiscent of some of the unashamedly propaganda plays of the early twentieth century, at the time of the battle for women's suffrage.
FT
was a feminist and suffragist. (Lindsay further suggests that her third child's middle name, Redmond, may signal sympathy with the cause of Irish independence: he may have been named after John Redmond
, a Home Ruler who died in 1918.) FT
, to the unease of her husband, attended suffrage meetings in Bournemouth. In her writings she noted the need for the vote and the value of the bicycle. On the latter point, she quoted a popular poem which had the housemaid and cook out bicycling while Daddy was doing the cooking—which, FT
observes, was very good for him.
Lindsay, Gillian. Flora Thompson: The Story of the Lark Rise Writer. Hale, 1996.
In 1859 Mill
reprinted this essay shortly after HT
's death in the second volume of his Dissertations and Discussions.
Hayek, Friedrich Augustus von et al. John Stuart Mill and Harriet Taylor; Their Correspondence [i.e. Friendship] and Subsequent Marriage. University of Chicago Press, 1951.
14
Mitchell, Sally, editor. Victorian Britain: An Encyclopedia. Garland Press, 1988.
502
He attributed the essay to its right author and claimed that she possesed a delicacy of perception, an accuracy and nicety of observation, only equalled by her profundity of speculative thought, and by a practical judgment and discernment next to infallible.
qtd. in
Hayek, Friedrich Augustus von et al. John Stuart Mill and Harriet Taylor; Their Correspondence [i.e. Friendship] and Subsequent Marriage. University of Chicago Press, 1951.
14
The essay was also later printed as a pamphlet and circulated by the Women's Suffrage Society
in 1868.
Kent, Susan Kingsley. Sex and Suffrage in Britain, 1860-1914. Princeton University Press, 1987.
188
Mitchell, Sally, editor. Victorian Britain: An Encyclopedia. Garland Press, 1988.
502
An edition of 1983 from Virago
calls the author Harriet Hardy Taylor Mill.
HBS
is remembered above all as having contributed substantially with Uncle Tom's Cabin to the build-up of anti-slavery feeling in the North before the Civil War. The sense of her influence is encapsulated in the possibly apocryphal comment which Abraham Lincoln
is supposed to have made upon meeting her in 1862: So you're the little woman who wrote the book that started this great war!
qtd. in
Hedrick, Joan. Harriet Beecher Stowe: A Life. Oxford University Press, 1994.
vii
Certainly the genre of anti-slavery narrative, of which she wrote the most powerful example, was hugely influential beyond the shores of her own country in proving that women's writing could legitimately address and materially affect matters of the greatest political importance. Elizabeth Barrett Browning
, in a letter to Anna Jameson
in 1855, argued that HBS
, above all women (yes, and men of the age) has moved the world—and for good.
Browning, Elizabeth Barrett. The Letters of Elizabeth Barrett Browning. Editor Kenyon, Frederic G., Macmillan, 1897, 2 vols.
2: 258
In an earlier letter written in 1853, Barrett Browning drew an analogy, common in mid-Victorian Britain, between slavery and gender inequality: I rejoice in [her] success, both as a woman and a human being. Oh, and is it possible that you think a woman has no business with questions like the question of slavery? Then she had better use a pen no more. She had better subside into slavery and concubinage herself, I think, as in the times of old, shut herself up with the Penelopes in the women's apartment, and take no rank among thinkers and speakers.
Browning, Elizabeth Barrett. The Letters of Elizabeth Barrett Browning. Editor Kenyon, Frederic G., Macmillan, 1897, 2 vols.
2: 110-11
Anna Leonowens
placed Uncle Tom's Cabin at the centre of her attack on Thailand's harems and slavery system in The English Governess at the Siamese Court (1870). The novel helped maintain a connection between white middle-class feminism and abolitionism that extended from the British anti-slavery campaign of the late eighteenth and early nineteenth century through to the abolitionist campaign against the Contagious Diseases Acts and the suffrage campaign, in which leaders such as Emmeline Pankhurst
were influenced by HBS
. In mid-twentieth century the US peace activist born Dorothy Rabinowitz
but remembered as Dorothy Stowe (co-founder of Greenpeace
) changed her name and that of her family in honour of HBS
, showing that reverence for her extended to supporters of causes not directly linked with that of slavery.
The National Union of Townswomen's Guilds
is a charity formed after the success of the struggle for the suffrage, and devoted to advancing the education of women (as well as to providing social amenities). It is particularly interested in education for good citizenship, to enable women to make a positive contribution in public life.