Though the
Feminist Companion says that Miss Silver is a character
[i]n the mould of Agatha Christie
's Miss Marple, she actually predates Miss Marple by two years. She is a former
governess who now runs her own detective agency, expending much of her professional earnings on the needs of others. She is formidably clever, but given a piquant unlikeliness in the role of detective by her old-lady appearance and her strict moral sense—which, however, often leads her to form judgements divergent from those of others. She sees straight through condescension and personal pretence. Like other fictional female sleuths (and indeed like actual women writers reporting human affairs), she is quick to exploit specifically feminine knowledge and understanding, and she has the gift of putting anxious clients at ease (particularly those to whom when they were children a
governess represented the principle of security). Her love of quoting
Tennyson
signifies her membership in an earlier generation. She works closely with the police, in the persons of Chief Inspector Lamb (introduced in
The Blind Side, 1939) and his subordinate Frank Abbott (who is on her wavelength as Lamb is not, since she was once his
governess, and is even bold enough to try to pass off on her a fake
Tennyson
quotation). The
Feminist Companion notes the ambivalent symbolism of Miss Silver's continual knitting: on the one hand this suggests motherly nurture, on the other hand the inexorable thread linking the evolution of a course of action, or the steps by which the detecting mind follows such a course. (The fact that
PW
set her first novel under the Terror during the French Revolution suggests that some further allusion to Madame Desfarges knitting at the guillotine would not have escaped her.)