Critical response was very positive. Gerald Massey
in the Athenæum proclaimed Browning a great dramatic poet and felt that Shakespeare
would have approved. Walter Bagehot
characterized his style as grotesque, a judgement which has stuck.
qtd. in
Irvine, William, and Park Honan. The Book, the Ring, and the Poet: A Biography of Robert Browning. McGraw-Hill, 1974.
397
Literary responses
Isa Craig
The Athenæum's reviewer Gerald Massey
thought IC
had failed in Duchess Agnes to capture the large human emotions she tried for, and found the Burns ode considerably strained and flamboyant and really unnatural to...
Publishing
Jean Ingelow
Rossetti
also benefited from JI
's success. Following the advice of a friend
, Ingelow wrote to an American publisher informing them that she was aware of literary piracy in America, and asking for...
Reception
Isa Craig
IC
's poem was chosen from among six hundred entries; other contestants included the working-class poet Gerald Massey
and diarist Arthur Munby
. Caroline Norton
, visiting Edinburgh that year, had also written a poetic...